Why IT Teams Choose Avatier Implementation Over ForgeRock (PingIdentity) Complexity

Identity management isn’t just another IT function—it’s a critical business enabler. As organizations navigate hybrid work environments, cloud migrations, and evolving security threats, their identity and access management (IAM) solutions must strike the perfect balance between robust security and operational simplicity.

This growing need for balance has sparked a significant shift in the market, with many IT teams reconsidering their commitment to complex platforms like ForgeRock (now owned by Ping Identity) in favor of more streamlined, user-friendly solutions like Avatier’s Identity Anywhere.

The Implementation Challenge: Complexity vs. Agility

ForgeRock has long been known for its comprehensive capabilities, but this power comes at a significant cost: implementation complexity. According to a 2023 Enterprise Strategy Group survey, 68% of organizations report that their IAM implementations take longer than initially planned, with ForgeRock implementations averaging 12-18 months before reaching full operational status.

In contrast, Avatier’s container-based architecture enables dramatically faster deployment cycles. The Identity-as-a-Container (IDaaC) approach allows for implementation timelines that are typically 60-70% shorter than traditional IAM platforms, with most organizations fully operational within 3-6 months.

Key Implementation Differentiators:

1. Pre-configured Connectors vs. Custom Coding

ForgeRock implementations often require extensive custom coding and configuration work. Their platform provides powerful flexibility but demands specialized expertise for even basic integrations. This translates to longer project timelines and higher implementation costs.

Avatier offers over 500 pre-configured application connectors that work out-of-the-box, dramatically reducing integration complexity. The platform’s intuitive design allows IT teams to establish connections with critical systems without extensive coding or specialized developer knowledge.

1. Container-Based Architecture vs. Monolithic Platform

ForgeRock’s traditional architecture requires significant infrastructure planning, with separate environments for development, testing, and production. Each environment demands careful configuration and synchronization.

Avatier’s container-based approach allows for simplified deployment across any infrastructure—whether on-premises, in the cloud, or in hybrid environments. This containerization enables rapid scaling and seamless updates without disruption to existing services.

1. Implementation Resource Requirements

A typical ForgeRock implementation requires a team of 4-6 specialized consultants working for 12+ months, often at rates exceeding $200/hour. This translates to implementation costs frequently surpassing $1 million before the system delivers any business value.

Avatier implementations typically require 2-3 consultants for 3-6 months, with many organizations able to handle significant portions of the implementation using internal resources thanks to Avatier’s intuitive configuration interfaces. The average implementation cost is 50-60% lower than comparable ForgeRock projects.

The User Experience Equation

Beyond implementation challenges, ForgeRock’s complexity extends to the end-user experience. According to a Gartner report, employee frustration with complex IAM interfaces results in a 26% increase in help desk tickets and significantly impacts productivity.

Avatier’s philosophy centers on simplifying identity management through intuitive interfaces and AI-driven assistance. The platform’s self-service capabilities empower users to handle routine tasks like password resets, access requests, and profile updates without IT intervention.

User Experience Comparison:

Feature	ForgeRock (PingIdentity)	Avatier
Self-Service Password Reset	Available but requires multiple steps	One-click process with AI-driven authentication
Access Request Interface	Form-based with complex approval workflows	Intuitive catalog-style interface with guided recommendations
Mobile Experience	Limited mobile functionality	Full-featured native mobile apps with biometric authentication
User Onboarding	IT-driven process	Self-service capabilities with automated provisioning

The impact of this user experience difference is substantial. Organizations that have switched from ForgeRock to Avatier report an average 72% reduction in identity-related help desk tickets and a 43% improvement in user satisfaction scores.

Security Without Sacrifice

Some organizations hesitate to move away from ForgeRock due to perceived security advantages. However, modern security requirements demand both robust protections and operational agility—areas where Avatier excels.

Avatier’s platform incorporates comprehensive access governance capabilities, including continuous access reviews, segregation of duties enforcement, and risk-based authentication. The solution meets rigorous compliance requirements for industries ranging from healthcare (HIPAA) to financial services (SOX, GLBA) to government (FISMA, NIST 800-53).

Advanced Security Capabilities:

1. Zero Trust Architecture

Both platforms support zero trust principles, but Avatier’s implementation focuses on operational simplicity. The platform provides continuous verification and least privilege access without creating excessive friction for legitimate users.

1. Adaptive Multi-Factor Authentication

Avatier’s multifactor integration goes beyond basic MFA to provide context-aware authentication that adjusts security requirements based on user behavior, location, device health, and other risk factors.

1. AI-Powered Threat Detection

Avatier leverages AI to identify anomalous access patterns and potential security threats in real-time, providing proactive protection against account takeover and insider threats.

The ROI Argument: Why IT Teams Are Making the Switch

The true test of any enterprise software is its return on investment. Here, the differences between ForgeRock and Avatier become even more pronounced.

According to a Forrester Total Economic Impact study, organizations implementing ForgeRock typically achieve ROI after 18-24 months. In contrast, Avatier customers report reaching ROI in 9-12 months on average, with some achieving positive returns in as little as 6 months.

This accelerated ROI stems from several factors:

1. Reduced Implementation Costs

Avatier’s streamlined implementation process requires fewer specialized resources and less time, reducing project costs by 50-60% compared to ForgeRock implementations.

2. Lower Operational Overhead

The intuitive nature of Avatier’s platform reduces the need for dedicated IAM specialists to manage day-to-day operations. Organizations report being able to manage their Avatier environment with 30-40% fewer resources than comparable ForgeRock deployments.

3. Help Desk Savings

Avatier’s self-service capabilities and intuitive interfaces reduce identity-related help desk tickets by an average of 72%, freeing IT resources for more strategic initiatives.

4. Faster Time-to-Value

With implementation timelines measured in months rather than years, organizations can begin realizing benefits from their Avatier investment significantly faster than with ForgeRock.

Real-World Impact: Case Study Highlights

Financial Services Leader

A mid-sized financial institution with approximately 5,000 employees had been struggling with their ForgeRock implementation for over 18 months. The project was behind schedule and over budget, with mounting concerns about user adoption.

After switching to Avatier, they completed their implementation in just 4 months. The organization reported:

• 85% reduction in password reset tickets
• 92% user satisfaction with the new system
• 60% faster user provisioning processes
• Full compliance with SOX and GLBA requirements

Healthcare System

A regional healthcare network with 12,000 employees and complex compliance requirements was facing challenges with their aging ForgeRock deployment. The system required multiple specialized administrators and struggled to keep pace with the organization’s growth.

Their migration to Avatier delivered:

• Complete HIPAA compliance with comprehensive audit capabilities
• 68% reduction in IAM-related operational costs
• 90% faster onboarding for clinical staff
• Seamless integration with their Electronic Health Record (EHR) system

Addressing Common Migration Concerns

Organizations considering a switch from ForgeRock to Avatier often share similar concerns:

“We’ve already invested significantly in ForgeRock.”

The sunk cost fallacy can keep organizations tied to underperforming systems. A proper TCO analysis that includes ongoing operational costs, specialized staffing requirements, and lost productivity due to complexity often reveals that migration to Avatier delivers positive ROI despite the initial investment in ForgeRock.

“Migration will disrupt our operations.”

Avatier’s professional services team specializes in migrations from complex IAM platforms. Their phased approach ensures continuity while transitioning to the new system, with many customers maintaining dual operations during the transition period to eliminate disruption.

“Our security requirements are too complex for a simpler solution.”

Avatier’s architecture is designed to address the most demanding security requirements without unnecessary complexity. The platform is deployed in highly regulated industries including defense, healthcare, and financial services, meeting stringent compliance requirements while maintaining operational simplicity.

The Path Forward: Simplifying Without Compromise

As identity management continues to evolve from a technical function to a strategic business enabler, organizations need solutions that balance robust security with operational efficiency. The shift from ForgeRock to Avatier represents a growing recognition that complexity itself does not equal security—and often undermines it by creating operational friction.

By focusing on user experience, implementation agility, and sustainable operations, Avatier delivers the core capabilities organizations need without the burden of unnecessary complexity. For IT teams tired of extended implementation timelines, specialized staffing requirements, and frustrated end users, Avatier offers a compelling alternative that doesn’t require sacrificing security or capabilities.

As one CISO who made the switch put it: “With ForgeRock, we spent more time managing our identity solution than it saved us. With Avatier, identity management finally delivers on its promise of simplifying security operations while enhancing our overall security posture.”

The balance of simplicity and security isn’t just desirable—it’s essential for sustainable security operations.

Try Avatier today