ForgeRock (PingIdentity) DaVinci vs Avatier’s Apollo: Which Self-Service Identity Platform Delivers Superior Results?

The demand for identity management solutions continues to grow, requiring organizations to strike a balance between strong security measures and seamless user experiences. With PingIdentity’s acquisition of ForgeRock in 2023, the DaVinci platform has gained attention as a customer identity and access management (CIAM) solution. Meanwhile, Avatier’s Apollo platform has been making waves with its innovative approach to identity lifecycle management. This comparison examines how these solutions stack up against each other across critical areas that matter most to enterprise security leaders.

The Evolution of Self-Service Identity Management

The identity and access management (IAM) market continues to expand rapidly, with Gartner projecting it to reach $26.2 billion by 2027, growing at a CAGR of 13.7%. Self-service capabilities have become essential in modern IAM solutions, addressing the dual challenges of reducing help desk costs while enhancing user satisfaction.

ForgeRock’s DaVinci, now under the PingIdentity umbrella, was initially designed as a no-code/low-code orchestration platform focused on customer identity journeys. Avatier’s Apollo, in contrast, was purpose-built as an enterprise-grade Identity Anywhere Lifecycle Management solution that prioritizes self-service across the full identity lifecycle.

User Experience & Self-Service Capabilities

ForgeRock DaVinci: Customer-Centric Design

DaVinci excels at creating customized authentication journeys for customer-facing applications. Its drag-and-drop interface allows organizations to design complex identity verification flows without extensive coding knowledge. The platform shines in consumer-facing scenarios where personalization and brand consistency are paramount.

However, DaVinci’s enterprise employee use cases sometimes lack the comprehensive workflow capabilities needed for complex corporate environments. While it provides solid self-service password management and basic access request features, it doesn’t match the depth of enterprise-specific self-service workflows found in other solutions.

Avatier Apollo: Enterprise Self-Service Redefined

Avatier’s Apollo platform takes a different approach, focusing on comprehensive self-service capabilities across the entire identity lifecycle. Its chatbot-driven interface allows users to request access, reset passwords, manage group memberships, and handle compliance attestations through natural language interactions.

What sets Apollo apart is its Identity Management Anywhere approach, delivering self-service capabilities through multiple channels:

• Mobile applications (iOS/Android)
• Desktop applications
• Web portal
• Chatbots (Microsoft Teams, Slack, etc.)
• Email
• SMS

This omnichannel strategy ensures users can access self-service functions through their preferred communication method, driving adoption rates significantly higher than industry averages. According to Enterprise Management Associates, organizations using mobile-enabled identity self-service see 35% higher user satisfaction scores and 42% lower help desk costs related to access management.

Integration Capabilities & Ecosystem

ForgeRock DaVinci: Strong in Customer Identity Ecosystems

DaVinci’s integration framework excels in customer-facing environments, with pre-built connectors to common authentication services, fraud detection tools, and consumer-facing applications. The platform offers approximately 150+ pre-built integrations, primarily focused on authentication and authorization services.

Since the PingIdentity acquisition, DaVinci has improved its enterprise connectivity, but still lags in depth of enterprise application provisioning compared to specialized identity governance and administration (IGA) solutions.

Avatier Apollo: Enterprise-Grade Connectivity

Avatier Apollo stands out with its comprehensive application connector library, supporting over 500+ enterprise applications and systems. This includes robust connectors to:

• HR systems (Workday, SAP SuccessFactors, UKG)
• Cloud platforms (AWS, Azure, GCP)
• Enterprise applications (ServiceNow, Salesforce, Oracle EBS)
• Directory services (Active Directory, Azure AD, LDAP)
• Privileged access management solutions

Apollo’s identity container architecture allows for rapid deployment of new connectors, with Avatier releasing updates at a pace 3x faster than the industry average. The platform’s identity-as-a-container approach enables organizations to deploy only the connectors they need, reducing unnecessary complexity.

Security & Compliance

ForgeRock DaVinci: Strong Authentication Focus

DaVinci excels at creating sophisticated authentication flows with multiple verification steps, making it well-suited for high-security consumer scenarios. Its risk-based authentication capabilities can adapt verification methods based on contextual risk factors.

From a compliance perspective, DaVinci offers solid audit logging and reporting capabilities but may require additional modules from the broader ForgeRock/Ping portfolio to address comprehensive compliance requirements across regulated industries.

Avatier Apollo: Enterprise Compliance by Design

Apollo takes a different approach, with compliance at its core architecture. The platform offers purpose-built solutions for various regulatory frameworks:

• HIPAA compliance for healthcare organizations
• FISMA and NIST 800-53 for government agencies
• SOX compliance for financial reporting
• NERC CIP for critical infrastructure
• FERPA for educational institutions

Apollo’s self-service access certification and attestation capabilities streamline compliance processes, with automated workflows that reduce the manual effort typically associated with access reviews. According to a Forrester study, organizations using automated access certification processes can reduce compliance costs by up to 40% while improving accuracy by 65%.

Deployment Options & Time-to-Value

ForgeRock DaVinci: Cloud-First Approach

DaVinci follows ForgeRock’s cloud-first strategy, with most implementations leveraging their Identity Cloud offering. On-premises deployments are possible but less common. Implementation timelines typically range from 3-6 months for moderate complexity deployments, with most of the effort focused on:

• Authentication flow design
• Integration with customer identity sources
• User interface customization
• Testing and validation

Avatier Apollo: Flexible Deployment with Rapid Results

Avatier differentiates itself with flexible deployment options:

• SaaS cloud service
• Customer-hosted cloud (AWS, Azure, GCP)
• On-premises
• Hybrid approaches

The unique Identity-as-a-Container (IDaaC) architecture allows for remarkably fast implementations, with many organizations going live in 8-12 weeks instead of the industry average of 6-9 months. This container-based approach also simplifies maintenance and upgrades, reducing total cost of ownership.

AI Capabilities & Future-Readiness

ForgeRock DaVinci: Emerging AI Integration

Following the PingIdentity acquisition, DaVinci has begun incorporating more AI-driven capabilities, primarily focused on:

• Risk-based authentication
• Fraud detection
• Basic anomaly identification

While these capabilities show promise, they remain focused predominantly on the authentication phase rather than across the entire identity lifecycle.

Avatier Apollo: Comprehensive AI Identity Automation

Apollo incorporates AI throughout the identity lifecycle with capabilities including:

• Natural language processing for chatbot interfaces
• Predictive access recommendations
• Anomalous access detection
• Role mining and optimization
• Access risk scoring
• Identity verification and proofing

A standout feature is Apollo’s AI-driven access request recommendations, which can analyze past approval patterns and suggest appropriate access levels based on peer groups. This capability has been shown to reduce inappropriate access requests by 43% while accelerating request approvals by 62%.

Cost Structure & ROI

ForgeRock DaVinci: Premium Pricing

DaVinci typically follows a user-based pricing model, with costs generally on the higher end of the market spectrum. While the platform delivers value for complex customer identity scenarios, the ROI calculation for employee-centric use cases may be less compelling, particularly for organizations without extensive consumer-facing identity requirements.

Avatier Apollo: Value-Based Pricing

Avatier’s pricing approach focuses on delivering maximum value with predictable costs. Rather than charging by individual user, the platform offers tier-based pricing that can result in significantly lower total costs for mid-size and large enterprises. Organizations typically report ROI within 6-9 months, driven by:

• 60-80% reduction in password reset calls
• 30-45% faster user provisioning
• 50-70% reduction in access certification effort
• 25-40% improved compliance posture

Real-World Performance: Which Platform Excels?

While both platforms offer compelling self-service capabilities, their ideal use cases differ significantly:

ForgeRock DaVinci is ideal for:

• Consumer-facing identity journeys requiring sophisticated authentication
• Organizations prioritizing brand-consistent user experiences
• Companies already invested in the ForgeRock/PingIdentity ecosystem
• Scenarios requiring complex authentication orchestration

Avatier Apollo excels for:

• Enterprise-wide identity lifecycle management
• Organizations seeking comprehensive self-service across multiple channels
• Environments with complex compliance requirements
• Companies prioritizing rapid deployment and quick ROI
• Those requiring sophisticated workflow automation beyond authentication

Making the Right Choice for Your Organization

When evaluating ForgeRock DaVinci versus Avatier Apollo, consider these key questions:

1. Is your primary focus customer identity or employee identity management?
2. What channels do your users prefer for self-service interactions?
3. How complex are your compliance requirements?
4. What is your target implementation timeline?
5. How important is integration with existing enterprise applications?

For organizations primarily concerned with employee identity management, comprehensive self-service capabilities, and enterprise integration, Avatier Apollo typically provides the more complete solution. Its multi-channel approach, extensive connector library, and AI-driven automation deliver exceptional value across the identity lifecycle.

For those focused predominantly on customer-facing identity scenarios with complex authentication requirements, ForgeRock DaVinci offers compelling capabilities, particularly when integrated with the broader PingIdentity portfolio.

As identity management continues to evolve, both platforms are making significant investments in AI capabilities. However, Avatier’s early focus on conversational interfaces and identity intelligence positions it advantageously in the rapidly evolving landscape of intelligent identity automation.

Ultimately, the right choice depends on your specific organizational needs, existing technology landscape, and strategic identity management priorities. By carefully evaluating both options against your unique requirements, you can select the platform that best positions your organization for identity management success.

Try Avatier today