The Premium Price Problem: ForgeRock (PingIdentity) vs Avatier Value – Is Enterprise IAM Worth the Cost?

Securing identity management is a critical challenge for organizations, especially while attempting to control costs. As enterprise IAM solutions become essential infrastructure rather than optional tools, CISOs and IT leaders must balance robust security features with budget realities. The acquisition of ForgeRock by Ping Identity in 2023 (creating a combined entity under the Ping umbrella) has spotlighted a persistent industry issue – premium pricing that often exceeds the actual value delivered.

This analysis examines the ForgeRock/Ping Identity pricing model compared to Avatier’s value proposition, helping decision-makers understand when premium prices are justified and where more cost-effective alternatives might better serve their organizational needs.

The Enterprise IAM Pricing Crisis

The identity and access management market continues its explosive growth, projected to reach $34.5 billion by 2028 with a CAGR of 13.7%. This acceleration is driven by increased remote work adoption, cloud migration, and rising security threats. However, this growth has also led to significant pricing disparities among vendors.

The ForgeRock/Ping Premium Pricing Model

ForgeRock and Ping Identity position themselves as premium enterprise IAM providers, with pricing structures that reflect this status. Their typical licensing models include:

1. Per-User Pricing: Often starting at $25-50 per user annually for basic functionality, escalating quickly with additional modules
2. Enterprise Licensing: Can exceed $500,000 annually for large organizations
3. Implementation Costs: Professional services and implementation can add 1.5-2x the software cost
4. Module-Based Pricing: Key security features are often segregated into additional cost modules

A midsize organization with 5,000 users might face annual ForgeRock/Ping licensing costs exceeding $250,000, before implementation and ongoing management expenses.

Hidden Costs in Premium IAM Solutions

Beyond the explicit pricing, ForgeRock and Ping implementations often include substantial hidden costs:

1. Professional Services Requirements: Complex deployments typically require 3-6 months of professional services
2. Specialized Staffing: Organizations often need dedicated specialists commanding salaries 15-25% higher than general IT staff
3. Upgrade Costs: Major version upgrades can require additional professional services engagements
4. Customization Expenses: Business-specific workflows often require costly custom development

One Fortune 500 company reported spending over $1.2 million on their ForgeRock implementation, with nearly 40% attributed to professional services and customization costs not initially factored into their budget.

Avatier’s Value-Based Alternative

Avatier Identity Management takes a fundamentally different approach to IAM pricing and value delivery. As organizations increasingly question premium pricing models, Avatier offers a compelling alternative:

Cost-Effective Licensing Structure

Avatier’s licensing model provides significant cost advantages:

1. Transparent Per-User Pricing: Typically 30-40% lower than ForgeRock/Ping equivalents
2. Comprehensive Feature Inclusion: Core security features included in base licensing
3. Flexible Deployment Options: Container-based deployment reduces infrastructure costs
4. Predictable Scaling: Linear cost scaling without enterprise-tier pricing jumps

Reduced Implementation Burden

Avatier’s architecture is designed for rapid deployment and self-sufficiency:

1. No-Code Configuration: Dramatically reduces implementation timelines
2. Container-Based Deployment: Identity-as-a-Container (IDaaC) simplifies infrastructure requirements
3. Self-Service Administration: Reduces ongoing specialist requirements
4. Pre-Built Connectors: Over 500 application connectors reduce integration costs

Total Cost of Ownership Analysis

When comparing Avatier to ForgeRock/Ping over a 3-year period, organizations typically experience:

• 40-60% reduction in initial implementation costs
• 30-45% lower annual licensing fees
• 25-35% reduction in ongoing administration costs
• 50-70% faster time-to-value

A financial services organization that switched from ForgeRock to Avatier reported a 42% reduction in total IAM spending while expanding their implementation scope to include additional security controls.

When Does Premium Pricing Make Sense?

While Avatier provides exceptional value for most organizations, there are specific scenarios where ForgeRock/Ping’s premium pricing may be justified:

Complex Global Deployments

Organizations with extremely complex global operations spanning dozens of countries with conflicting regulatory requirements might benefit from ForgeRock’s extensive professional services network. However, Avatier’s international capabilities now support most global enterprises, with multi-language support and region-specific compliance frameworks.

Unusual Technical Requirements

Enterprises with highly specialized technical requirements might find value in ForgeRock’s extensive customization capabilities. However, Avatier’s modern API-first architecture now supports equivalent integration capabilities for most use cases.

Existing Ping/ForgeRock Ecosystem Investment

Organizations heavily invested in the broader Ping or ForgeRock ecosystem might find integration benefits that offset the premium pricing. However, Avatier’s extensive application connectors provide equivalent integration capabilities at a lower cost.

Real-World Value Comparison: Core IAM Capabilities

When evaluating the actual security and operational value delivered, Avatier matches or exceeds ForgeRock/Ping capabilities in key areas while maintaining cost advantages:

Identity Lifecycle Management

ForgeRock/Ping:

• Comprehensive lifecycle management
• Complex implementation requirements
• Module-based pricing increases costs for full functionality

Avatier:

• Complete lifecycle management solution
• No-code configuration reduces implementation time by 50-70%
• Inclusive pricing model includes full functionality
• Mobile-first approach increases user adoption

Access Governance

ForgeRock/Ping:

• Robust access certification capabilities
• Extensive reporting options
• Often requires additional modules and pricing

Avatier:

• Comprehensive access governance included in base licensing
• AI-driven certification recommendations reduce administrative burden
• Risk-based certification scheduling optimizes reviewer workloads
• Continuous compliance monitoring vs. point-in-time reviews

Authentication and MFA

ForgeRock/Ping:

• Market-leading MFA capabilities
• Extensive authentication methods
• Often requires premium pricing tiers

Avatier:

• Comprehensive MFA integration
• Support for all standard authentication methods
• Seamless integration with existing MFA investments
• Included in base licensing

Self-Service Capabilities

ForgeRock/Ping:

• Comprehensive self-service options
• Complex implementation
• Often requires professional services to configure

Avatier:

• Industry-leading self-service capabilities
• Password management reduces help desk calls by up to 85%
• Group self-service reduces access request processing time by 70%
• Mobile-first approach increases user adoption rates

Industry-Specific Value Considerations

Different industries have unique IAM requirements that impact the value equation:

Healthcare

Healthcare organizations must balance strict HIPAA requirements with tight IT budgets. While ForgeRock offers healthcare solutions, Avatier’s HIPAA-compliant identity management provides equivalent security controls at a significantly lower price point, typically saving 30-40% while maintaining compliance.

Financial Services

Financial institutions require robust security and compliance controls. Avatier’s financial services solutions provide the security depth of premium-priced alternatives while offering faster implementation and lower TCO.

Government and Military

Public sector organizations face both strict security requirements and budget constraints. Avatier’s FISMA, FIPS 200 & NIST SP 800-53 compliant solutions provide a cost-effective alternative that meets government standards without premium pricing.

The Evolving Value Equation

The IAM marketplace continues to evolve, with several trends affecting the value equation:

Commoditization of Core IAM Features

Many capabilities once considered premium features have become standardized across the industry. Organizations should question whether they’re paying premium prices for now-standard functionality.

Container-Based Deployment

Avatier pioneered the Identity-as-a-Container approach, significantly reducing infrastructure and management costs compared to traditional deployments.

AI and Automation Integration

Both ForgeRock/Ping and Avatier are incorporating AI capabilities, but Avatier includes these innovations without premium pricing upcharges.

Shifting Budget Priorities

With 76% of CISOs reporting budget constraints as a major challenge, according to a recent cybersecurity industry survey, cost-effectiveness has become a critical decision factor in IAM selection.

Making the Right Value Decision

When evaluating ForgeRock/Ping versus Avatier, organizations should consider:

1. Total Cost Analysis: Look beyond licensing to include implementation, ongoing management, and upgrade costs
2. Value-Feature Alignment: Identify which premium features truly deliver value for your specific use cases
3. Deployment Timeline: Consider the business impact of implementation timeframes
4. Self-Sufficiency: Evaluate the long-term staffing implications of each solution
5. Future Flexibility: Assess how each vendor’s roadmap aligns with your organization’s strategic direction

Conclusion: Redefining IAM Value

The premium pricing model employed by ForgeRock/Ping reflects an earlier era of IAM, when implementation complexity and specialized expertise were unavoidable. Avatier has fundamentally transformed this equation by delivering enterprise-grade security with dramatically simplified implementation and management.

For most organizations, the value gap between premium-priced solutions and Avatier has widened significantly. While specific use cases may still justify ForgeRock/Ping’s premium pricing, the majority of enterprises will find that Avatier delivers equivalent or superior security outcomes at a substantially lower total cost.

As identity management continues its evolution from specialized security function to core business infrastructure, cost-effectiveness without security compromise has become the new standard of IAM value—a standard where Avatier consistently outperforms premium-priced alternatives.

By choosing value over premium pricing, organizations can redirect significant resources to other security priorities while maintaining robust identity controls—a compelling proposition in today’s budget-conscious security landscape.

Try Avatier today