Customer Success Rates: Avatier vs ForgeRock (PingIdentity) Implementation Results

Successful identity management implementations can mean the difference between streamlined operations and costly security breaches. As organizations evaluate their options between established providers like ForgeRock (now part of PingIdentity) and innovative platforms like Avatier, understanding implementation success rates becomes crucial for technology decision-makers.

The Current State of Identity Management Implementations

Identity and Access Management (IAM) implementations have historically suffered from high failure rates. According to Gartner, approximately 50% of IAM projects fail to meet expectations or face significant delays. This sobering statistic underscores the challenges organizations face when deploying comprehensive identity solutions.

The landscape has become even more complex with ForgeRock’s recent acquisition by PingIdentity, leaving many customers uncertain about the future direction of their identity infrastructure. This market consolidation has created an opportunity to reassess implementation approaches and success rates across different providers.

Implementation Success Metrics: A Comparative Analysis

When comparing Avatier’s Identity Management Anywhere platform with ForgeRock (PingIdentity) implementations, several key performance indicators emerge:

1. Time-to-Implementation

Avatier:

• Average implementation time: 4-6 weeks
• Container-based deployment reduces configuration time by up to 70%
• Pre-configured connectors enable rapid integration with existing systems

ForgeRock (PingIdentity):

• Average implementation time: 6-12 months
• Complex customization requirements often extend timelines
• Additional professional services typically required for deployment

The dramatic difference in implementation timelines stems from Avatier’s innovative Identity-as-a-Container (IDaaC) approach, which significantly simplifies deployment across diverse environments. This containerized architecture provides a consistent experience whether deployed on-premises, in hybrid environments, or fully in the cloud.

2. Integration Success Rates

Avatier:

• 98% successful integration rate with existing systems
• 200+ pre-built application connectors
• Custom connector development within days, not months

ForgeRock (PingIdentity):

• 85% successful integration rate with existing systems
• Complex integrations often require additional customization
• Lengthier timelines for custom connector development

Avatier’s extensive library of application connectors provides out-of-the-box integration with virtually any enterprise system, significantly reducing the need for custom development and ensuring higher implementation success rates.

3. User Adoption and Satisfaction

Avatier:

• 92% user satisfaction rate post-implementation
• Mobile-first design increases adoption rates by 35%
• Self-service capabilities reduce help desk tickets by 70%

ForgeRock (PingIdentity):

• 76% user satisfaction rate post-implementation
• Mobile experiences often require additional configuration
• More complex self-service workflows lead to lower adoption rates

Avatier’s focus on user experience—particularly through intuitive self-service capabilities and mobile-friendly design—consistently leads to higher user satisfaction and adoption rates. This user-centric approach is exemplified in Avatier’s Password Management solution, which simplifies one of the most common identity-related tasks.

Implementation Challenges and Resolution Approaches

Both platforms face implementation challenges, but their approaches to resolution differ significantly:

Complex Regulatory Environments

Avatier: Avatier’s modular approach allows organizations to implement specific compliance controls without rearchitecting their entire identity infrastructure. For regulated industries like healthcare, HIPAA-compliant identity management solutions come pre-configured to address specific regulatory requirements.

ForgeRock (PingIdentity): ForgeRock implementations typically require significant customization to address industry-specific compliance requirements, often leading to longer implementation timelines and higher costs.

Legacy System Integration

Avatier: Avatier’s architecture was designed with legacy system integration in mind, offering specialized connectors for mainframe systems, legacy HR applications, and custom in-house solutions. This approach minimizes disruption to existing operations while modernizing identity management capabilities.

ForgeRock (PingIdentity): ForgeRock implementations often require more extensive customization and middleware development to connect with legacy systems, increasing both complexity and project risk.

Identity Governance and Compliance

Avatier: Avatier’s Access Governance solution provides built-in controls for compliance automation, attestation, and role management, enabling organizations to implement robust governance practices from day one.

ForgeRock (PingIdentity): ForgeRock’s governance capabilities typically require additional components and configuration, complicating implementation and potentially extending timelines.

Real-World Implementation Case Studies

Fortune 500 Financial Services Organization

A leading financial services organization with 50,000+ employees was evaluating both Avatier and ForgeRock for their identity management modernization initiative. Their requirements included:

• Integration with 300+ applications
• Strict regulatory compliance (SOX, GLBA, PCI-DSS)
• 24/7 global availability
• Self-service capabilities for end users

ForgeRock Proposal:

• 12-18 month implementation timeline
• $2.5M in professional services
• Custom development for 40% of required integrations
• Separate mobile implementation project

Avatier Implementation Results:

• 14-week implementation timeline
• 85% reduction in professional services costs
• 100% integration success without custom development
• Unified mobile experience included in base implementation

The organization selected Avatier’s Identity Management Anywhere for Financial solution and achieved full implementation in just over three months, with a 94% user satisfaction rating within the first year.

Healthcare Provider Network

A healthcare provider network with 30+ facilities and 25,000 employees needed to replace their legacy identity solution with a modern platform supporting:

• HIPAA compliance
• Integration with Epic and other clinical systems
• Streamlined clinical workflow access
• Rapid onboarding for rotating medical staff

ForgeRock (PingIdentity) Estimated Implementation:

• 9-12 month implementation timeline
• Significant customization for clinical workflows
• Additional modules required for HIPAA compliance
• Complex identity lifecycle management configuration

Avatier Implementation Results:

• 8-week phased implementation
• Pre-built HIPAA compliance controls
• Specialized healthcare connectors included
• 65% reduction in onboarding time for clinical staff

By selecting Avatier’s purpose-built healthcare identity solution, the organization achieved compliance objectives while dramatically improving clinician satisfaction and productivity.

The AI Advantage in Implementation Success

A key differentiator in Avatier’s higher implementation success rates is its strategic integration of AI throughout the identity lifecycle:

Avatier AI Implementation Benefits:

• Intelligent workflow recommendations reduce configuration time by 40%
• Anomaly detection prevents 92% of potential security issues during migration
• Automated access reconciliation ensures clean data transfer
• Predictive analytics guide resource allocation during deployment

ForgeRock (PingIdentity) AI Approach:

• More limited AI capabilities in the implementation phase
• Manual configuration validation processes
• Higher reliance on human expertise for data quality management
• Less predictive capability for resource planning

Avatier’s AI-enhanced implementation methodology has proven particularly valuable for complex enterprises with diverse identity populations and multiple integration points.

Total Cost of Implementation: Beyond Software Licensing

When evaluating implementation costs, organizations must consider factors beyond initial licensing:

Avatier Total Implementation Cost Factors:

• Reduced professional services requirements
• Minimal customization needs
• Lower internal resource demands
• Faster time-to-value

ForgeRock (PingIdentity) Total Implementation Cost Factors:

• Higher professional services requirements
• Extensive customization often needed
• Greater internal resource demands
• Longer time-to-value

Organizations implementing Avatier typically report 30-50% lower total implementation costs compared to ForgeRock (PingIdentity) implementations of similar scope and scale.

Implementation Best Practices from Successful Deployments

Regardless of platform choice, certain implementation best practices increase the likelihood of success:

1. Start with clear use cases and measurable objectives
2. Implement in phases rather than attempting “big bang” deployments
3. Prioritize user experience and adoption from the beginning
4. Establish robust testing processes, particularly for integrations
5. Develop a clear data governance strategy before implementation
6. Provide adequate user training and support resources
7. Measure and communicate success metrics throughout the implementation

Avatier’s Professional Services team incorporates these best practices into every implementation, contributing to significantly higher success rates compared to industry averages.

Conclusion: Making an Informed Implementation Choice

The implementation success gap between Avatier and ForgeRock (PingIdentity) reflects fundamental differences in architecture, approach, and organizational focus:

• Avatier’s containerized, modular architecture enables faster, more reliable implementations
• Pre-built industry solutions address specialized requirements without extensive customization
• User-centric design drives higher adoption rates and satisfaction
• AI-enhanced implementation methodologies reduce risk and accelerate timelines

As organizations evaluate their identity management options, implementation success rates should be a primary consideration—not just feature comparisons or initial licensing costs. The most comprehensive feature set provides limited value if implementation delays or failures prevent organizations from realizing those benefits.

By prioritizing implementation success factors in the selection process, organizations can significantly increase their chances of achieving desired identity management outcomes while reducing costs, minimizing disruption, and accelerating time-to-value.

Try Avatier today