The True Cost of ForgeRock Maintenance: Why Avatier’s Configuration-First Approach Delivers Better ROI

Many organizations find themselves trapped in a cycle of escalating costs and complexity after implementing solutions from vendors like ForgeRock (now part of Ping Identity). These hidden expenses can significantly impact your total cost of ownership (TCO) and erode the anticipated return on investment.

According to a recent industry analysis, organizations spend an average of 2.5-3x their initial license costs on ongoing maintenance, customization, and professional services for complex IAM deployments. This article explores why ForgeRock deployments often lead to unexpectedly high maintenance costs and how Avatier’s configuration-first approach provides a more sustainable and cost-effective alternative.

The Hidden Maintenance Burden of ForgeRock Deployments

ForgeRock, now under the Ping Identity umbrella following a $2.8 billion acquisition, has built its platform on a development-intensive framework that requires specialized technical expertise to maintain. While powerful, this approach creates several cost challenges:

1. Heavy Customization Requirements

ForgeRock’s platform is known for its extensive customization capabilities, which initially appears beneficial. However, this flexibility comes with a significant cost: nearly every implementation requires custom development work. According to Gartner, organizations typically spend 60-70% of their IAM budgets on implementation and ongoing maintenance rather than on the software itself.

The platform’s architecture necessitates JavaScript development for even moderate customizations. Each workflow modification, attribute mapping change, or integration adjustment requires technical intervention rather than simple configuration changes. This reliance on development resources creates:

• Longer deployment timelines (averaging 12-18 months vs. industry standard of 6-9 months)
• Dependency on specialized, expensive technical resources
• Complexity that grows with each customization
• Difficulty adapting to changing business requirements

2. Specialized Talent Requirements

ForgeRock implementations demand specialized technical expertise, creating a resource dependency that increases costs and risks:

• ForgeRock administrators command premium salaries (15-25% higher than typical IAM administrators)
• Limited talent pool leads to higher contractor rates ($175-250/hour for ForgeRock specialists)
• Knowledge transfer challenges when key personnel leave
• Training costs for new staff (typically $5,000-10,000 per technical resource)

According to a 2023 IAM workforce survey, organizations with heavily customized IAM solutions report 40% higher staffing costs and 35% longer time-to-fill positions compared to those with configuration-based solutions.

3. Upgrade Complexities

Perhaps the most significant hidden cost comes during upgrade cycles. ForgeRock’s development-centric approach means that customizations often need substantial reworking during version upgrades:

• Custom code must be verified and frequently modified for compatibility
• Integrations require retesting and potential redevelopment
• Workflows may need reconstruction to maintain functionality
• Extended testing cycles to ensure all custom components function properly

A recent industry survey revealed that organizations with heavily customized IAM environments spend 3-4x more on upgrade projects and experience 2-3x longer upgrade timelines compared to those with configuration-centric solutions.

4. Documentation and Knowledge Management

With ForgeRock’s development approach, organizations must maintain extensive documentation of all customizations:

• Custom code requires thorough documentation
• Development decisions must be recorded for future reference
• Changes to the base platform must be tracked across versions
• Knowledge management becomes increasingly complex over time

The survey mentioned earlier found that 68% of organizations with heavily customized IAM deployments reported significant challenges in maintaining adequate documentation, leading to increased risk and dependency on key personnel.

Avatier’s Configuration-First Approach: A More Sustainable Alternative

Avatier’s Identity Anywhere Lifecycle Management platform takes a fundamentally different approach, prioritizing configuration over customization. This design philosophy delivers several key advantages that directly address ForgeRock’s maintenance challenges:

1. No-Code Configuration for Business Users

Avatier’s platform is designed to be managed primarily through configuration rather than coding:

• Intuitive administrative interfaces eliminate coding requirements
• Business analysts can implement changes without developer intervention
• Workflow adjustments can be made through drag-and-drop interfaces
• Integration mappings managed through visual tools rather than code

This approach reduces dependency on specialized technical resources, lowering ongoing operational costs by 40-60% compared to development-heavy platforms like ForgeRock.

2. Self-Contained Upgrade Paths

One of Avatier’s most significant advantages is its upgrade methodology:

• Configurations are preserved during version upgrades
• No custom code to rewrite or adapt to new versions
• Automated testing ensures compatibility of existing configurations
• Significantly faster upgrade cycles (days instead of months)

Organizations using configuration-centric IAM solutions like Avatier report 70-80% lower upgrade costs compared to heavily customized alternatives. According to industry analysts, the average Avatier customer completes major version upgrades in 2-4 weeks, compared to 3-6 months for typical ForgeRock deployments.

3. Broader Resource Availability

Avatier’s configuration approach democratizes who can manage and maintain the platform:

• System administrators can be trained in days rather than weeks
• Knowledge transfer is simplified through intuitive interfaces
• Documentation requirements focus on business processes, not technical implementations
• Less dependency on specialized technical expertise

Organizations report that Avatier administrators typically require 50-60% less specialized training compared to ForgeRock administrators, with corresponding reductions in personnel costs and risks.

4. Enterprise-Grade Capabilities Without the Complexity

Despite its focus on simplicity, Avatier’s Access Governance platform delivers enterprise-scale capabilities:

• Comprehensive lifecycle management
• Robust access governance and certification
• Advanced password management and multi-factor authentication
• Pre-built connectors for hundreds of applications
• Compliance reporting and audit support

The platform achieves this while maintaining a configuration-centric approach that significantly reduces maintenance burden. According to customer testimonials, organizations typically realize a 40-60% reduction in total cost of ownership over a five-year period compared to development-heavy alternatives like ForgeRock.

Real-World Impact: TCO Comparison

To illustrate the difference in maintenance costs, let’s examine a typical mid-sized enterprise deployment with 10,000 users:

ForgeRock Implementation:

• Initial license/implementation: $750,000-950,000
• Annual maintenance (license): $150,000-190,000
• Custom development costs (initial): $300,000-500,000
• Ongoing development/maintenance: $200,000-300,000/year
• Specialized staff/contractors: $250,000-350,000/year
• Major upgrade (every 2-3 years): $200,000-400,000 per upgrade
• Five-year TCO: $2.5-3.5 million

Avatier Implementation:

• Initial license/implementation: $650,000-850,000
• Annual maintenance (license): $130,000-170,000
• Configuration costs (initial): $100,000-200,000
• Ongoing configuration/maintenance: $60,000-100,000/year
• Staff training/support: $50,000-100,000/year
• Major upgrade (every 2-3 years): $40,000-80,000 per upgrade
• Five-year TCO: $1.2-1.7 million

These figures reflect industry averages and customer-reported data, showing that Avatier’s configuration approach can reduce total cost of ownership by 40-60% compared to ForgeRock’s development-intensive model.

Beyond Cost: Operational Benefits of Configuration vs. Customization

The advantages of Avatier’s configuration-first approach extend beyond direct cost savings:

1. Faster Time-to-Value

Avatier deployments typically reach production readiness in 4-6 months, compared to 12-18 months for heavily customized ForgeRock implementations. This accelerated timeline means:

• Faster realization of security improvements
• Quicker compliance achievements
• Earlier operational efficiency gains
• Reduced project risk and scope creep

2. Improved Agility and Adaptability

When business requirements change, Avatier’s configuration approach enables much faster adaptation:

• New workflows can be implemented in days rather than weeks
• Attribute mapping changes don’t require development cycles
• Integration adjustments can be made by administrators rather than developers
• Policy modifications can be implemented immediately

This agility becomes particularly valuable in merger/acquisition scenarios, reorganizations, and regulatory changes, where time-to-compliance is critical.

3. Reduced Dependency Risk

Organizations with heavily customized ForgeRock deployments often find themselves dependent on specific individuals or contractors who understand their implementation. This creates business continuity risks that Avatier’s approach minimizes:

• Configuration knowledge is easier to transfer
• Documentation is simpler and more standardized
• New administrators can be trained more quickly
• Vendor support can more effectively assist with issues

4. Simplified Compliance Management

For regulated industries, Avatier’s compliance-focused design provides significant advantages:

• Pre-built compliance reports and dashboards
• Automated audit trail for all identity actions
• Simplified segregation of duties enforcement
• Streamlined certification campaigns

These capabilities are delivered through configuration rather than custom development, making compliance maintenance significantly less resource-intensive.

Making the Switch: Migrating from ForgeRock to Avatier

For organizations currently struggling with ForgeRock maintenance costs, migrating to Avatier offers a path to significant cost reduction and operational improvement. Avatier provides:

• Migration tools and methodologies specifically designed for ForgeRock transitions
• Data mapping templates to preserve existing identity information
• Phased implementation approaches to minimize disruption
• Professional services with ForgeRock migration experience

While any migration involves some transition costs, organizations typically recover these expenses within 12-18 months through reduced maintenance and operational costs.

Conclusion: Configuration as a Strategic Advantage

The choice between ForgeRock’s development-intensive approach and Avatier’s configuration-centric platform represents more than a technical decision—it’s a strategic one with long-term financial implications.

By prioritizing configuration over customization, Avatier delivers a more sustainable, cost-effective identity management solution that reduces dependency on specialized resources, accelerates deployment and change cycles, and significantly lowers total cost of ownership.

For organizations seeking to optimize their identity management investments, Avatier’s approach offers a compelling alternative to the escalating maintenance costs and complexity of ForgeRock implementations. The result is not just cost savings but a more agile, adaptable identity infrastructure that can evolve with your business needs without requiring constant development investment.

As identity management continues to grow in strategic importance, choosing a platform designed for sustainable operation becomes increasingly critical. Avatier’s configuration-first approach provides this sustainability while delivering the enterprise-grade capabilities modern organizations demand.

Try Avatier today