ForgeRock (PingIdentity) Hidden Fees vs Avatier’s All-Inclusive Pricing: What CISOs Need to Know

Identity and Access Management (IAM) solutions are essential investments for enterprises. However, the true cost of these platforms often extends far beyond the initial quote. With ForgeRock’s acquisition by Ping Identity (completed in 2023), many organizations are discovering unexpected cost increases and hidden fees that weren’t apparent during the initial procurement process.

This comprehensive analysis examines the real cost of ownership between ForgeRock (now part of Ping Identity) and Avatier’s Identity Management Anywhere, helping CISOs and IT decision-makers understand the financial implications of their IAM strategy.

The Hidden Cost Reality of ForgeRock Solutions

When evaluating ForgeRock (now under Ping Identity), many organizations focus on the base licensing costs without fully accounting for the additional expenses that emerge throughout implementation and operation.

Implementation Costs: Just the Beginning

ForgeRock implementations typically require specialized expertise, often necessitating:

• Professional services engagements that can cost 2-3x the annual license fee
• Extended implementation timelines (6-12 months on average)
• Dedicated technical resources with specialized ForgeRock certification

According to a 2023 Gartner report, the average IAM implementation costs for complex solutions like ForgeRock can exceed 200% of the first-year licensing costs.

The Module Pricing Trap

ForgeRock’s licensing model is modular, which sounds flexible in theory but often leads to unexpected costs:

1. Base IAM Functionality vs. Advanced Features: Critical capabilities like adaptive authentication, advanced analytics, and comprehensive identity governance are frequently sold as add-on modules, each with their own licensing costs.
2. Integration Fees: Each connector to third-party applications often incurs additional costs, especially for custom or less common integrations.
3. Scalability Premiums: As your user base grows, you may hit licensing thresholds that trigger significant price increases. This “success tax” makes budgeting difficult as your organization grows.
4. Environmental Charges: Development, testing, staging, and disaster recovery environments all potentially require additional licensing, multiplying your base costs.

Post-Implementation Expenses

Many ForgeRock customers report significant ongoing expenses after implementation:

• Consulting Dependency: Complex customizations often create a perpetual dependency on ForgeRock consultants or specialized partners.
• Upgrade Costs: Major version upgrades frequently require professional services engagement, with costs ranging from $50,000 to $150,000 depending on implementation complexity.
• Training Investments: Specialized ForgeRock training for IT staff can cost $3,000-$5,000 per person annually.

Avatier’s Transparent, All-Inclusive Approach

In contrast to ForgeRock’s complex pricing structure, Avatier has built its reputation on transparent, predictable pricing that aligns with both security and financial objectives.

Comprehensive Base Package

Avatier’s Identity Anywhere Lifecycle Management solution includes core capabilities without nickel-and-diming for essential features:

• User lifecycle management from onboarding to offboarding
• Self-service password management and multi-factor authentication
• Access certification and governance
• Extensive pre-built application connectors
• Mobile and chatbot interfaces for anywhere access

Implementation Without Hidden Surprises

Avatier’s approach significantly reduces implementation complexity and cost:

• Streamlined Deployment: Typical implementations complete in 8-12 weeks rather than 6-12 months
• Container-Based Architecture: Reduces infrastructure complexity and overhead
• No-Code Customization: Empowers in-house teams to make changes without expensive consultants

Predictable Operational Expenses

Avatier’s pricing model eliminates unexpected operational costs:

1. Unlimited Environments: Development, testing, staging, and production environments are included without additional fees.
2. Connector Library Access: Over 500 pre-built connectors are included in your subscription, not priced à la carte.
3. All-Inclusive Updates: Version upgrades are designed to be self-implementable without requiring paid professional services.
4. No User Tier Penalties: Gradual growth doesn’t trigger sudden pricing jumps, making budgeting predictable.

Real-World Cost Comparison

Let’s examine how these differences translate to real-world costs for a mid-sized enterprise with 5,000 users:

Cost Category	ForgeRock/Ping	Avatier
Base Annual Licensing	$250,000	$200,000
Implementation Services	$400,000-600,000	$100,000-150,000
Additional Modules/Features	$75,000-150,000	Included
First Year Total	$725,000-1,000,000	$300,000-350,000
Annual Operational Costs	$75,000-125,000	$25,000-50,000
3-Year TCO	$950,000-1,375,000	$375,000-500,000

These figures represent industry averages based on customer feedback and analyst reports. The difference in total cost of ownership over three years can exceed $800,000 – a significant variance that often isn’t apparent during initial vendor evaluations.

Beyond Cost: The Value Proposition

While cost is a critical factor, the value delivered by your IAM solution ultimately determines ROI. Avatier’s approach provides several advantages beyond financial savings:

1. Faster Time to Value

Avatier customers typically see full deployment in 2-3 months, compared to ForgeRock’s 6-12 month average. This accelerated timeline means:

• Security improvements implemented sooner
• Faster realization of operational efficiencies
• Reduced project risk and resource drain

2. Operational Autonomy

Avatier’s platform is designed for self-sufficiency:

• No-code customization empowers IT teams to adapt the system without vendor dependency
• Intuitive administration reduces specialized knowledge requirements
• Self-service capabilities minimize help desk burden

According to Forrester research, organizations with high levels of IAM self-service capability reduce help desk calls by up to 40%, representing significant operational savings.

3. Enhanced User Experience

Avatier’s unified approach to identity management creates a superior experience:

• Consistent interfaces across all identity functions
• Mobile-first design for anywhere access
• Chatbot and virtual assistant integration for frictionless interactions

Why CISOs and IT Leaders Are Switching to Avatier

The shift from ForgeRock/Ping to Avatier is accelerating among enterprises seeking both cost optimization and enhanced capabilities:

Budgetary Predictability

With volatile economic conditions, unpredictable IAM costs create significant challenges. Avatier’s transparent pricing model allows for accurate long-term budgeting without surprise expenses.

Reduced Vendor Dependency

Many organizations report feeling “locked in” to ForgeRock due to the specialized expertise required to maintain their implementations. Avatier’s approach emphasizes customer autonomy and reduces this dependency.

Alignment with Modern Security Frameworks

Avatier’s container-based architecture and zero-trust design principles align perfectly with modern security frameworks and cloud-first strategies, without requiring premium pricing for these capabilities.

Making the Transition: Practical Considerations

For organizations considering a switch from ForgeRock/Ping to Avatier, several factors can facilitate a smooth transition:

1. Phased Migration: Rather than a complete “rip and replace,” many organizations implement Avatier alongside ForgeRock, gradually transitioning services.
2. ROI Analysis: Develop a comprehensive ROI analysis that accounts for both hard costs (licensing, implementation) and soft costs (operational efficiency, reduced help desk load).
3. User Experience Priorities: Identify high-impact user experiences (password resets, access requests) for initial migration to demonstrate quick wins.
4. Leverage Existing Data: Avatier can typically import user entitlements, access policies, and historical certification data from ForgeRock, preserving your governance history.

Conclusion: Transparency as a Core Value

In the IAM market, pricing transparency isn’t merely a purchasing consideration—it reflects a vendor’s overall approach to customer relationships. Avatier’s commitment to all-inclusive pricing aligns with its broader philosophy of making identity management more accessible, understandable, and valuable to the organizations it serves.

As identity management continues to increase in strategic importance, CISOs and IT leaders must look beyond feature checklists to understand the total financial impact of their IAM choices. ForgeRock (now Ping Identity) offers powerful capabilities but often at a significant and sometimes unpredictable cost. Avatier delivers comprehensive identity management with transparent, predictable pricing that allows organizations to accurately budget while achieving their security and compliance objectives.

By choosing an IAM solution with clear, all-inclusive pricing, organizations can avoid budget surprises, accelerate time-to-value, and maintain the flexibility to adapt their identity strategy as business needs evolve.

Whether you’re evaluating your first enterprise IAM solution or considering alternatives to your current platform, understanding the true cost implications of different vendor approaches is essential to making decisions that serve both your security requirements and financial responsibilities.

Try Avatier today