Why Governance Projects Succeed More with Avatier than SailPoint: A Comprehensive Comparison

Successful identity governance implementation has become a critical factor in enterprise security strategy. While SailPoint has established itself as a known player in the identity governance and administration (IGA) market, organizations increasingly find that Avatier’s Access Governance solutions deliver superior results with faster time-to-value, better user experiences, and more effective automation capabilities.

The High Stakes of Identity Governance Implementation

Identity governance projects are notoriously complex. According to Gartner, more than 50% of identity governance implementations take longer than expected or fail to meet business objectives. This sobering statistic highlights the critical need for solutions that prioritize implementation success.

When comparing Avatier and SailPoint, the differences in implementation approaches become immediately apparent – and these differences directly impact project success rates.

Implementation: Where Avatier Establishes Its Advantage

Deployment Timeframes: Weeks vs. Months

One of the most striking differences between Avatier and SailPoint implementations is deployment time. Avatier implementations typically complete in 6-12 weeks, while SailPoint projects often extend 9-18 months. This dramatic difference stems from Avatier’s architectural advantages:

• Container-Based Architecture: Avatier’s pioneering Identity-as-a-Container (IDaaC) approach allows for rapid deployment with minimal infrastructure requirements
• Preconfigured Connectors: Avatier’s extensive library of application connectors arrives ready for implementation
• Workflow Templates: Avatier provides industry-specific workflow templates that accelerate configuration

In contrast, SailPoint implementations typically require extensive customization, professional services, and longer integration timelines. For enterprises facing tight security deadlines or compliance requirements, this time difference can be decisive.

Implementation Complexity and Resource Requirements

SailPoint implementations demand significant technical expertise and consultant involvement. Many organizations report needing dedicated SailPoint specialists, increasing total cost of ownership. As one CISO from a Fortune 500 financial services company noted, “We had to maintain a team of three full-time SailPoint experts just to keep our implementation functioning.”

Avatier takes a fundamentally different approach with:

• Self-Service Implementation Tools: Avatier’s intuitive configuration interfaces require less specialized knowledge
• Simplified Architecture: Less complex integration requirements mean existing IT staff can handle more implementation tasks
• Comprehensive Professional Services: When expert help is needed, Avatier’s focused services teams deliver specific outcomes

This reduced complexity directly impacts project success rates, as fewer complex dependencies mean fewer potential failure points.

User Experience: A Critical Success Factor

The Adoption Challenge

The success of any governance solution ultimately depends on user adoption. When identity governance systems are difficult to use, they face resistance, workarounds, and ultimately, security vulnerabilities. According to a Forrester study, user experience issues account for approximately 30% of governance project failures.

Superior User Interfaces Drive Better Results

Avatier’s modern, intuitive user interfaces deliver significantly higher adoption rates. Key advantages include:

• Mobile-First Design: Avatier provides true mobile experiences through native apps for iOS and Android
• Chatbot Integration: Avatier’s identity management interfaces work within familiar collaboration tools like Teams and Slack
• Simplified Approval Flows: Managers can approve access requests with one click directly from email

SailPoint has made strides in improving its user experience but still tends toward more complex interfaces designed primarily for IAM specialists rather than everyday users.

Self-Service Capabilities That Users Actually Use

Both solutions offer self-service capabilities, but Avatier’s emphasis on usability results in much higher utilization rates. Avatier’s password management self-service adoption rates typically exceed 90%, compared to industry averages of 60-70% for competing solutions.

For organizations implementing Group Self-Service, the difference is particularly notable. Avatier’s group management interfaces allow business users to manage group memberships with minimal training, reducing administrative overhead while maintaining strict governance.

Automation: The Foundation of Governance Success

Workflow Automation Capabilities

Effective governance requires automating complex workflows across the identity lifecycle. While both platforms offer workflow capabilities, Avatier’s approach delivers more practical automation with:

• No-Code Workflow Builder: Business analysts can create and modify workflows without developer intervention
• Event-Driven Architecture: Avatier’s systems respond automatically to organizational changes
• Delegation Controls: Workflows can include delegation rules when approvers are unavailable

These automation advantages translate directly to governance success metrics, with Avatier customers reporting 60-85% reductions in manual identity administration tasks compared to previous solutions.

AI-Enhanced Governance

Avatier has made significant investments in AI-driven governance capabilities. The latest Identity Anywhere Spring 2025 release incorporates advanced machine learning algorithms that:

• Detect anomalous access patterns
• Recommend appropriate access based on peer groups
• Automate access certification decisions based on risk scoring
• Identify potential separation of duties violations

While SailPoint has also invested in AI capabilities, Avatier’s implementation focuses more on practical automation of everyday governance tasks rather than complex analytics that require specialist interpretation.

Certification Campaigns: The True Test of Governance Effectiveness

Access certification campaigns represent one of the most challenging aspects of governance implementation. These periodic reviews ensure appropriate access rights are maintained across the organization.

Certification Completion Rates

Organizations using Avatier consistently report higher certification completion rates:

• Avatier customers: 95-98% completion within deadline
• Industry average: 70-85% completion

This difference stems from Avatier’s focus on manager experience during certifications:

• Simplified interfaces showing only relevant information
• Bulk approval options for common scenarios
• Mobile-friendly certification interfaces
• Automated reminders and escalations

Certification Quality

Beyond completion rates, the quality of certification decisions matters tremendously. Avatier’s contextual information presentation helps managers make better decisions:

• Clear visibility into how access was originally granted
• Usage statistics showing if access is actually being used
• Risk scoring to highlight high-risk access for closer review
• Peer comparison to identify outlier access patterns

These capabilities result in more meaningful certifications, with Avatier customers reporting 30-40% higher revocation rates of inappropriate access compared to previous governance solutions.

Compliance Outcomes: The Bottom Line for Governance Success

The ultimate measure of governance success is compliance outcomes. Here, Avatier demonstrates particular strength in regulated industries:

Regulatory Compliance Success

Organizations in regulated industries face stringent compliance requirements. Avatier’s specialized solutions for HIPAA compliance, SOX compliance, and NIST 800-53 have proven particularly effective.

A major healthcare provider that switched from SailPoint to Avatier reported: “Our audit findings related to identity governance decreased by 78% in the first year after implementing Avatier. The automated controls and clear audit trails have transformed our compliance posture.”

Audit-Ready Reporting

Both solutions provide compliance reporting, but Avatier’s approach emphasizes:

• Pre-built compliance report templates mapped to specific regulations
• Automated evidence collection
• Real-time compliance dashboards
• Delegated compliance reporting for business units

This focus on practical compliance outcomes rather than theoretical governance capabilities delivers measurable business value.

Total Cost of Ownership: The Hidden Success Factor

While project success isn’t solely determined by cost, budget overruns can derail even well-planned governance initiatives. The total cost of ownership difference between Avatier and SailPoint is significant:

Implementation Costs

• Professional Services: SailPoint implementations typically require 2-3x more professional services hours
• Internal Resources: SailPoint projects demand more internal IT resources for longer periods
• Deployment Timeframe: Longer SailPoint deployments increase project management costs

Ongoing Operational Costs

• Staffing Requirements: SailPoint typically requires dedicated specialists for maintenance
• Upgrade Complexity: SailPoint upgrades often require significant professional services
• Integration Maintenance: More complex integrations require more ongoing support

For many organizations, these cost differences directly impact project success by influencing scope decisions, phasing strategies, and executive support.

Scalability: Supporting Growth Without Disruption

Governance requirements inevitably grow and change. Avatier’s architecture provides advantages for scaling governance programs:

User Base Scaling

Avatier’s container-based architecture allows for simple horizontal scaling as user populations grow. This contrasts with SailPoint’s more traditional architecture that may require infrastructure upgrades to accommodate growth.

Application Coverage Expansion

As organizations add new applications to their governance scope, Avatier’s application connector library streamlines expansion. New connectors can typically be implemented in days rather than weeks.

Geographic Expansion

For global organizations, Avatier’s internationalization capabilities support governance expansion across regions with localized interfaces in over 14 languages.

Conclusion: Why Avatier Delivers More Successful Governance Projects

While both Avatier and SailPoint can provide identity governance capabilities, organizations consistently achieve better outcomes with Avatier due to:

1. Faster Implementation: Weeks instead of months means faster time-to-value
2. Superior User Experience: Higher adoption rates drive better governance outcomes
3. Practical Automation: More effective automation of everyday governance tasks
4. Compliance Focus: Solutions designed for practical compliance outcomes
5. Lower Total Cost: More predictable costs with fewer specialized resource requirements

For CISOs and security leaders evaluating governance solutions, these advantages translate directly to project success metrics. While SailPoint remains a significant player in the market, organizations increasingly find that Avatier delivers the practical governance capabilities they need with less complexity, faster implementation, and better business outcomes.

As identity governance continues to evolve in response to emerging threats and compliance requirements, Avatier’s focus on user experience, automation, and practical compliance capabilities positions it as the superior choice for organizations serious about governance success.

Try Avatier today