Beyond Complexity: Why Enterprises Are Switching from ForgeRock to Avatier’s Streamlined IAM Approach

Identity and access management (IAM) has become a cornerstone of enterprise security strategy. However, not all IAM solutions deliver the same implementation experience or long-term value. As organizations increasingly prioritize both security and operational efficiency, the contrast between complex deployment models and streamlined approaches has become a decisive factor in vendor selection.

ForgeRock (now part of Ping Identity following their 2023 acquisition) has established itself as a major player in the IAM space. But many organizations are discovering that complexity in deployment, management, and scaling is hampering their security transformation journeys. This has led to a growing shift toward more streamlined solutions like Avatier’s Identity Anywhere platform.

The Hidden Costs of Complex IAM Deployments

ForgeRock deployments are known for their extensive customization capabilities but often require significant technical expertise and resources. According to a 2023 Enterprise Strategy Group report, 76% of organizations using complex IAM solutions report implementation timelines extending beyond initial projections, with average delays of 4-6 months.

This complexity manifests in several key areas:

1. Extended Implementation Timelines

ForgeRock implementations typically require specialized consultants and extensive professional services. The average ForgeRock enterprise deployment takes 6-12 months to complete, with large enterprises reporting timelines extending to 18+ months. This extended timeline not only delays security improvements but significantly increases total cost of ownership.

A Security Director at a Fortune 500 company who switched from ForgeRock to Avatier remarked, “We spent nearly a year configuring our ForgeRock deployment and still weren’t fully operational. With Avatier, we were live across our entire organization in under three months.”

2. Technical Expertise Requirements

ForgeRock’s architecture demands deep technical expertise in identity management protocols, APIs, and customization frameworks. Many organizations find themselves dependent on expensive consultants or dedicated specialists to maintain their IAM infrastructure.

According to a 2023 Gartner report, organizations with complex IAM deployments spend an average of 42% more on ongoing maintenance and support compared to those with more streamlined solutions.

3. Customization Complexity

While ForgeRock’s customization capabilities are robust, implementing these customizations often requires extensive coding and specialized knowledge. Organizations frequently report that what seemed like simple customizations became complex projects requiring significant developer resources.

Avatier’s Streamlined Approach: Simplicity Without Compromise

In contrast to ForgeRock’s complexity, Avatier’s Identity Anywhere platform has pioneered a streamlined approach to IAM that doesn’t sacrifice enterprise-grade capabilities. This approach manifests across several dimensions:

1. Containerized Deployment for Rapid Implementation

Avatier revolutionized IAM deployment with the industry’s first identity management container technology. The Identity-as-a-Container (IDaaC) approach allows organizations to deploy comprehensive IAM functionality in hours rather than months. This containerized architecture provides:

• Deployment times measured in hours instead of months
• Simplified scaling across complex environments
• Reduced dependency on specialized implementation resources
• Consistent performance across on-premises, cloud, and hybrid environments

A Director of Information Security at a healthcare provider noted, “We had budgeted six months for our IAM migration. With Avatier’s containerized approach, we were operational in three weeks, and our IT team could handle most of the configuration themselves.”

2. No-Code Configuration vs. Custom Development

Where ForgeRock often requires extensive custom development for tailored workflows, Avatier employs a no-code configuration approach that empowers IT teams to create and modify IAM processes without specialized development skills:

• Graphical workflow builders replace custom coding requirements
• Business rules can be modified through intuitive interfaces
• Changes can be implemented in minutes rather than days
• Reduced dependency on specialized developers

This approach not only accelerates implementation but significantly reduces ongoing maintenance costs. According to Avatier’s customer data, organizations spend 65% less time on routine IAM maintenance after switching from development-heavy platforms like ForgeRock.

3. Self-Service Focus Reduces Administrative Burden

Avatier’s platform was built from the ground up with self-service at its core, not as an afterthought. The user-friendly self-service capabilities include:

• Intuitive access request workflows
• Automated approval routing
• Self-service password management
• Group membership self-administration
• Mobile-first access to all IAM functions

This self-service focus has proven to deliver tangible operational benefits. Organizations that implement Avatier report an average 73% reduction in access-related help desk tickets and an 82% decrease in password reset support requirements.

Real-World Impact: Deployment Speed and Time-to-Value

The contrast between ForgeRock and Avatier is perhaps most evident in the implementation timeline and path to value:

ForgeRock Typical Implementation Journey:

1. Months 1-3: Initial architecture and planning with specialized consultants
2. Months 3-6: Core infrastructure deployment and integration with existing systems
3. Months 6-9: Workflow customization and policy implementation
4. Months 9-12: User migration, testing, and initial rollout
5. Months 12+: Ongoing refinement and expansion to additional use cases

Avatier Typical Implementation Journey:

1. Week 1: Container deployment and core configuration
2. Weeks 2-4: Integration with existing identity sources and target systems
3. Weeks 4-8: Policy implementation and workflow configuration
4. Weeks 8-12: User onboarding and full production deployment

This accelerated timeline doesn’t just save on implementation costs—it fundamentally changes how quickly organizations realize security and operational benefits from their IAM investments.

Total Cost of Ownership: The Long-Term Advantage

Beyond initial implementation, the TCO difference between complex and streamlined IAM approaches becomes increasingly pronounced over time:

1. Staffing and Expertise Costs

ForgeRock deployments typically require:

• Dedicated IAM specialists with specialized training
• Ongoing consultant engagements for major changes
• Developer resources for customizations

Avatier deployments typically require:

• Existing IT staff with minimal specialized training
• Occasional professional services for complex integrations
• Minimal developer involvement for customizations

2. Upgrade Complexity and Costs

ForgeRock’s highly customized deployments often make version upgrades complex and expensive. Many organizations report that major upgrades effectively become re-implementation projects.

In contrast, Avatier’s containerized approach simplifies upgrades to routine operations that can be performed with minimal disruption. The container architecture isolates core functionality from customizations, preventing upgrade conflicts.

3. Scalability Economics

As organizations grow, the economic impact of IAM architecture choices becomes more pronounced. ForgeRock’s complex deployment model often results in non-linear cost scaling as organization size increases.

Avatier’s container architecture creates predictable, linear scaling costs, with organizations reporting consistent performance from small departments to global enterprise deployments.

Compliance and Security: No Compromise Required

Organizations sometimes assume that streamlined IAM solutions sacrifice security depth or compliance capabilities. However, Avatier’s compliance capabilities match or exceed those of more complex platforms while making them more accessible:

• Comprehensive Compliance Coverage: Full support for NIST 800-53, HIPAA, SOX, GDPR, CCPA, and industry-specific regulations
• Automated Compliance Workflows: Pre-built processes for access certification, segregation of duties, and privileged access management
• Simplified Auditing: Comprehensive audit trails with intuitive reporting interfaces
• Zero-Trust Architecture: Built-in support for modern zero-trust principles without complex configuration

A CISO at a financial services firm noted, “We initially worried that moving from ForgeRock to Avatier would mean sacrificing compliance depth. In reality, we found Avatier’s compliance capabilities more comprehensive and significantly easier to demonstrate to auditors.”

The Human Factor: User Experience and Adoption

Perhaps the most overlooked advantage of Avatier’s streamlined approach is its impact on user adoption. Complex IAM deployments often result in cumbersome user experiences that drive shadow IT and workarounds.

Avatier’s focus on intuitive interfaces and mobile-first design has demonstrated measurable improvements in security behavior:

• 94% of users complete access certifications on time (vs. industry average of 65%)
• 88% reduction in password-related security incidents
• 78% increase in timely access revocation
• 91% user satisfaction ratings for IAM-related processes

Making the Switch: Migration Considerations

For organizations considering a migration from ForgeRock to a more streamlined approach like Avatier, several key considerations can ensure a smooth transition:

1. Inventory Current Capabilities: Document which ForgeRock capabilities are actively used versus theoretically available
2. Prioritize User Journeys: Focus on the most frequent identity-related workflows first
3. Phase Implementation: Consider a gradual approach starting with high-impact, low-complexity functions
4. Leverage Professional Services: Utilize Avatier’s migration expertise to accelerate the transition

Conclusion: Balancing Power and Pragmatism

The shift from complex IAM deployments like ForgeRock to streamlined approaches like Avatier represents a broader trend in enterprise security: prioritizing implementation speed and operational efficiency alongside technical capabilities.

As identity becomes increasingly central to security strategy, the ability to rapidly deploy, easily maintain, and seamlessly scale IAM capabilities has become as important as the depth of those capabilities. Avatier’s approach demonstrates that organizations no longer need to choose between powerful IAM and practical implementation.

For organizations evaluating their IAM strategy, the question is shifting from “Which solution has the most features?” to “Which solution will deliver the most value in the shortest time with the least complexity?” Increasingly, the answer is pointing toward streamlined approaches that prioritize real-world implementation over theoretical capability.

Try Avatier today