Why Avatier’s Employee-Centric Identity Management Outperforms ForgeRock’s Split Portfolio

Effective identity management isn’t just about security—it’s about enabling productivity. While many vendors like ForgeRock (acquired by Ping Identity in 2022) offer robust technical capabilities, they often miss the mark on what matters most: the everyday experience of employees who interact with these systems.

According to Gartner, organizations that prioritize employee experience in their identity management approach see up to 40% higher employee retention and 17% higher productivity. Yet despite these compelling statistics, many enterprises continue implementing fragmented identity solutions that frustrate users and burden IT teams.

This disconnect reveals the fundamental difference between Avatier’s approach and ForgeRock’s portfolio: one is built around how people work, while the other is built around technical architecture.

The Problem with ForgeRock’s Split Portfolio Approach

ForgeRock’s acquisition by Ping Identity created one of the largest identity management conglomerates in the market, but size doesn’t always translate to coherence. The combined entity offers a broad range of capabilities across consumer and workforce identity, but this breadth comes at the cost of integration complexity.

ForgeRock’s portfolio has historically been divided into distinct products:

• ForgeRock Identity Platform
• ForgeRock Identity Governance
• ForgeRock Identity Gateway
• ForgeRock Directory Services
• ForgeRock Access Management

Each component requires separate implementation, configuration, and maintenance—creating technical silos that ultimately manifest as friction in the employee experience. This fragmentation creates several significant challenges:

1. Disjointed User Interfaces

Employees must navigate multiple interfaces for different identity-related tasks. Password resets might happen in one system, while access requests require another, and identity verification occurs in yet another. This fragmentation creates confusion and reduces productivity.

2. Inconsistent Policy Enforcement

With policies managed across multiple systems, ensuring consistent enforcement becomes challenging. This increases security risks and complicates compliance efforts.

3. Higher Total Cost of Ownership

Multiple systems mean multiple implementation projects, maintenance contracts, upgrade cycles, and specialized skill sets. A Forrester study found that organizations with fragmented identity systems spend up to 30% more on operational costs compared to those with unified approaches.

4. Extended Implementation Timelines

Integrating disparate systems extends project timelines. While ForgeRock claims rapid deployment, the reality of connecting their split portfolio often means implementation timelines extending 12-18 months before realizing value.

Avatier’s Unified Employee Experience Approach

In contrast to ForgeRock’s technical fragmentation, Avatier’s Identity Management solutions take a fundamentally different approach by unifying the employee experience across all identity touchpoints. This approach creates several distinct advantages:

1. Single Interface for All Identity Needs

Avatier provides employees with a single, intuitive interface for all identity-related tasks—from password resets to access requests, group management, and compliance attestations. This unified experience significantly reduces training needs and support tickets.

With Avatier’s Identity Anywhere platform, employees access self-service identity functions through familiar interfaces, including:

• Mobile apps
• Microsoft Teams
• Slack
• ServiceNow
• Custom web portals

The impact is substantial: organizations implementing Avatier’s unified approach report a 60% reduction in help desk calls related to identity management, according to internal customer studies.

2. Consistent Policy Enforcement

By centralizing policy management, Avatier ensures consistent enforcement across all identity processes. This uniformity simplifies compliance efforts and strengthens security posture.

Avatier’s Access Governance capabilities build compliance directly into everyday workflows, making it easier to maintain regulatory alignment without disrupting employee productivity.

3. Lower Total Cost of Ownership

Avatier’s unified approach translates to significant cost savings:

• 40% lower implementation costs compared to multi-product solutions
• 25% reduction in ongoing operational expenses
• Simplified license management through all-in-one pricing

These savings are particularly pronounced when compared to ForgeRock’s licensing model, which typically requires separate licenses for each component of their portfolio.

4. Rapid Time to Value

While ForgeRock implementations often span 12+ months, Avatier’s containerized deployment approach dramatically accelerates time to value:

• Initial implementation in weeks, not months
• Self-contained architecture eliminates complex integrations
• Pre-built connectors for over 500 business applications
• No code/low code configuration capabilities

Real-World Impact: Employee-Centric vs. Technology-Centric

The difference between Avatier’s and ForgeRock’s approaches becomes most apparent when examining real-world scenarios that employees face daily:

Scenario 1: Onboarding New Employees

ForgeRock Approach:

• HR initiates onboarding in the HR system
• IT receives notification and manually provisions accounts across multiple systems
• Access rights require separate approval workflows
• Device provisioning happens in yet another system
• Average time to productivity: 3-5 days

Avatier Approach:

• HR initiates onboarding in the HR system
• Avatier’s Lifecycle Management automatically provisions all required accounts, access rights, and resources based on role
• Approvals are handled through a unified workflow
• All provisioning activities are tracked in a single console
• Average time to productivity: Less than 1 day

Scenario 2: Access Request Process

ForgeRock Approach:

• Employee navigates to separate access request portal
• Requests must be mapped to specific systems and entitlements
• Approvals follow different paths depending on the system
• Fulfillment requires coordination across multiple platforms
• Average request fulfillment time: 2-3 days

Avatier Approach:

• Employee makes request through any familiar interface (Teams, Slack, mobile app)
• AI-powered recommendations suggest appropriate access rights
• All approvals follow a unified workflow
• Automatic provisioning occurs upon approval
• Average request fulfillment time: 4 hours

Scenario 3: Compliance Reviews

ForgeRock Approach:

• Separate certification processes for different systems
• Reviewers navigate multiple interfaces
• Inconsistent user information across systems
• Manual correlation of access rights
• Average completion time: 3-4 weeks

Avatier Approach:

• Single, comprehensive certification process
• Intuitive interface with risk-based highlighting
• All user information consolidated in one view
• Automated recommendations for access revocation
• Average completion time: 1-2 weeks

The Technology Behind Avatier’s Advantage

Avatier’s employee-centric advantage isn’t just philosophical—it’s built into the architecture. Unlike ForgeRock’s disparate components, Avatier offers:

1. Container-Based Architecture

Avatier pioneered the Identity-as-a-Container (IDaaC) approach, which enables:

• Deployment anywhere (cloud, on-premises, hybrid)
• Consistent experience regardless of deployment model
• Seamless updates without disruption
• Scalability without additional complexity

2. Integration-First Design

Rather than forcing organizations to adapt to its systems, Avatier integrates with existing workflows:

• Native integration with collaboration tools (Teams, Slack)
• Embedded functionality in service management platforms
• Mobile-first design for today’s distributed workforce
• No-code/low-code customization capabilities

3. AI-Enhanced Experience

Avatier incorporates AI throughout the identity lifecycle:

• Predictive access recommendations based on peer groups
• Risk scoring for certification prioritization
• Anomaly detection for potential security issues
• Natural language processing for intuitive requests

Making the Switch: ROI Considerations

Organizations considering a transition from ForgeRock to Avatier typically see substantial return on investment:

• 40-60% reduction in identity-related help desk tickets
• 70% faster access provisioning
• 30% improvement in security posture through consistent policy enforcement
• 25-40% lower total cost of ownership

The most significant returns, however, come from improved employee productivity and satisfaction. When identity management works seamlessly in the background—rather than creating friction—employees can focus on their core responsibilities.

Beyond Technical Features: Cultural Alignment

Perhaps the most fundamental difference between Avatier and ForgeRock lies in organizational philosophy. ForgeRock, particularly following its acquisition by Ping Identity, operates as a large enterprise focused on technical capabilities and market position.

Avatier, in contrast, maintains an employee-centric focus that aligns with how modern workforces operate. This philosophical difference manifests in every aspect of the product, from design decisions to implementation methodologies to support processes.

Conclusion: Employee Experience as Competitive Advantage

In today’s competitive talent landscape, employee experience has become a critical differentiator. Identity management—often overlooked as merely a security function—plays a surprisingly significant role in shaping that experience.

Organizations that implement Avatier’s unified, employee-centric approach gain more than just technical capabilities; they create a foundation for workforce enablement that directly impacts productivity, security, and satisfaction.

While ForgeRock’s portfolio offers comprehensive technical capabilities, its fragmented approach creates friction that ultimately undermines the very security and efficiency it aims to provide. By focusing on employee experience first, Avatier delivers both stronger security outcomes and higher productivity—proving that these goals can be complementary rather than competing.

For organizations seeking to transform identity management from a necessary security control into a genuine business enabler, the choice between Avatier’s unified approach and ForgeRock’s split portfolio becomes clear: employee experience is the new competitive advantage.

Try Avatier today