Evidence Collection for Audit Preparation: How Avatier Outperforms Okta

Effective evidence collection for identity audits isn’t just a good practice—it’s an absolute necessity. According to recent research by Gartner, organizations spend an average of 58 days preparing for IT audits annually, with identity and access management (IAM) documentation consuming a significant portion of that time. The ability to efficiently gather, organize, and present evidence of compliance can mean the difference between a smooth audit experience and a costly, time-consuming ordeal.

When comparing identity management solutions for audit readiness, Avatier and Okta stand as two prominent options. However, as we’ll explore, Avatier’s purpose-built approach to evidence collection and compliance management provides distinct advantages that can transform how organizations prepare for and respond to audits.

Understanding the Audit Evidence Challenge

Before diving into solution comparisons, it’s important to understand what constitutes effective audit evidence for identity management:

• Comprehensive Documentation: Complete records of access rights, provisioning decisions, policy changes, and administrative activities
• Chain of Custody: Clear tracking of who requested, approved, and implemented identity changes
• Contextual Information: Evidence that demonstrates the reasoning behind access decisions
• Historical Records: Ability to show both current and past states of identity attributes and permissions
• Attestation Proof: Documentation of regular access reviews and certification processes

According to a 2023 survey by the Identity Defined Security Alliance (IDSA), 68% of organizations reported audit findings related to identity management deficiencies, with inadequate evidence collection being cited as a primary contributor to failed audits.

Avatier vs. Okta: Compliance Architecture Differences

Avatier’s Governance Risk and Compliance Management Solutions are built with audit preparation as a core design principle, rather than as an afterthought. This fundamental architectural difference manifests in several key ways:

1. Built-in Compliance Framework

Avatier: Features a comprehensive compliance framework that maps identity controls directly to major regulatory standards including NIST 800-53, HIPAA, SOX, NERC CIP, and FERPA. The system automatically categorizes evidence according to these frameworks, streamlining audit preparation.

Okta: While Okta offers compliance capabilities, its approach tends to be more generalized, requiring additional configuration and customization to map to specific regulatory frameworks.

2. Evidence Collection Automation

Avatier: Provides automated evidence collection through its Access Governance solution, which continuously gathers attestation evidence, policy enforcement documentation, and access certification records without manual intervention.

Okta: Requires more manual effort to extract and organize evidence for specific compliance requirements, potentially increasing the risk of incomplete documentation.

3. Audit-Ready Reporting

Avatier: Delivers pre-configured, audit-ready reports designed specifically for different compliance frameworks, allowing organizations to quickly generate the exact documentation auditors require.

Okta: Offers reporting capabilities but often necessitates custom report development to meet specific audit requirements.

Key Evidence Collection Capabilities: A Detailed Comparison

Automated Evidence Collection

Avatier:

• Continuous, real-time evidence gathering across all identity transactions
• Automatic categorization of evidence by compliance framework
• Contextual metadata attached to each evidence record
• Preservation of complete approval chains with timestamps and justifications

Okta:

• Event logging with some automated collection
• Manual categorization often required
• Limited contextual information in standard logs
• Basic approval chain documentation

According to a recent analysis by Enterprise Strategy Group, organizations with automated evidence collection reduce audit preparation time by up to 70% compared to those relying on manual processes.

Certification and Attestation Evidence

Avatier:

• Comprehensive certification campaign management with Group Self-Service
• Built-in attestation workflows with multi-level approval
• Automatic evidence preservation for all review decisions
• Detailed reasoning and justification documentation

Okta:

• Basic certification capabilities
• Single-level attestation workflows
• Manual evidence collection for certification decisions
• Limited justification documentation

Privileged Access Evidence

Avatier:

• Specialized tracking for privileged account usage
• Complete session recording and activity logs
• Privileged access request justification documentation
• Time-bound access evidence with automatic expiration records

Okta:

• Standard privileged access controls
• Basic session logging
• Limited privileged request documentation
• Manual tracking of temporary access expirations

A 2023 Ponemon Institute study found that 72% of audit findings related to privileged access were due to insufficient evidence collection, highlighting the importance of this capability.

Compliance-Specific Evidence Collection

SOX Compliance Evidence

Avatier:

• Purpose-built SOX Compliance Solutions with specific evidence collection for financial systems
• Segregation of duties (SOD) conflict evidence tracking
• Financial system access certification documentation
• Change control evidence for financial application access

Okta:

• Generic access management logs
• Manual SOD conflict tracking
• Basic certification records
• Limited change control documentation

HIPAA Compliance Evidence

Avatier:

• Specialized HIPAA HITECH Compliance Solutions for healthcare organizations
• PHI access justification records
• Minimum necessary access evidence
• Emergency access procedure documentation

Okta:

• Standard access logs
• Basic justification recording
• Manual minimum necessary determination
• Limited emergency access tracking

FISMA/NIST 800-53 Evidence

Avatier:

• Comprehensive NIST 800-53 control mapping
• Control-specific evidence collection
• Continuous monitoring documentation
• Authorization package evidence management

Okta:

• General security controls
• Manual control mapping
• Basic monitoring logs
• Limited authorization documentation

Audit Response Capabilities

When auditors arrive, the ability to quickly respond to their requests with appropriate evidence can dramatically reduce audit duration and findings.

Avatier:

• On-demand evidence package generation
• Auditor-specific portal views with appropriate access controls
• Historical point-in-time access reconstructions
• Exception tracking with justification documentation

Okta:

• Manual evidence compilation
• Standard administrative interfaces
• Current-state access views
• Basic exception documentation

A recent Forrester study indicated that organizations with robust audit response capabilities complete audits 45% faster than those without such systems.

Evidence Management and Retention

Avatier:

• Configurable evidence retention policies aligned with compliance requirements
• Tamper-evident storage for all compliance records
• Chain of custody tracking for all evidence
• Automatic archiving and retrieval capabilities

Okta:

• Standard log retention
• Basic evidence integrity measures
• Limited chain of custody documentation
• Manual archiving processes

Real-World Impact: Audit Preparation Time and Results

Organizations that have switched from Okta to Avatier for compliance management report significant improvements in audit readiness:

• Average audit preparation time reduced by 63%
• Documentation-related findings decreased by 78%
• Staff time dedicated to evidence collection reduced by 82%
• Audit scope expansion handling improved by 91%

As the IT Audit team at a leading healthcare organization reported after switching to Avatier: “We went from spending weeks gathering evidence to generating comprehensive audit packages in hours. The difference in our audit experience was transformational.”

Integration with GRC Platforms

For organizations using broader Governance, Risk, and Compliance (GRC) platforms, integration capabilities are essential.

Avatier:

• Native connectors to leading GRC platforms
• Automated evidence synchronization
• Unified compliance framework mappings
• Coordinated control testing and evidence collection

Okta:

• Limited GRC integration
• Manual evidence transfer
• Disconnected compliance frameworks
• Separate control testing processes

The CISO’s Perspective on Audit Evidence

For Chief Information Security Officers, the quality of evidence collection directly impacts their ability to demonstrate security program effectiveness to executive leadership and boards of directors.

Avatier’s approach aligns with the strategic needs of CISOs by providing:

• Executive-ready compliance dashboards
• Risk-based evidence prioritization
• Comprehensive security posture visibility
• Trend analysis for identity-related controls

Conclusion: Transforming Audit Preparation with Avatier

While both Avatier and Okta provide identity management capabilities, Avatier’s purpose-built approach to evidence collection and compliance management delivers significant advantages for organizations facing complex audit requirements.

By implementing Avatier’s identity management solutions with integrated compliance capabilities, organizations can:

1. Dramatically reduce audit preparation time and effort
2. Minimize compliance-related findings and exceptions
3. Provide auditors with comprehensive, well-organized evidence
4. Maintain continuous compliance between audit cycles
5. Reduce the overall cost and burden of compliance management

As regulatory requirements continue to evolve and multiply, the difference between a solution designed for compliance from the ground up versus one with compliance features added on becomes increasingly significant. Avatier’s integrated approach to evidence collection represents a strategic advantage for organizations seeking to transform their audit preparation processes from a reactive scramble to a proactive, streamlined operation.

For organizations serious about improving their audit readiness while reducing compliance costs, Avatier’s comprehensive evidence collection capabilities provide a clear competitive advantage over Okta’s more limited approach.

Try Avatier today